My older brother Steven died on November 10th.
He was a year and a half older than me. He’d been living with a heavy addiction for more than a decade, and on November 10th, it took him.
That same day, I received my license number, the milestone I’d spent years working toward. The day I officially became a Licensed Marriage and Family Therapist is the day my brother officially left.
I keep turning that over. My mom’s Parkinson’s and Steven’s addiction were the two reasons I first walked into a therapist’s office. That room changed my life so completely that I decided to spend the rest of it sitting in the other chair. And on the day the door to that life finally opened all the way, he was gone.
The next day was 11/11. I don’t know exactly what I believe about portals. But it did feel like one. A door closing and a door opening, and me standing in the frame between them, not sure which way to face.
—————
The strange thing about losing someone to addiction is that you’ve usually been losing them for a long time.
I grieved Steven for years while he was still alive. I just didn’t call it grief. I called it anger.
And I had reasons. After years of trying to help him, I learnt (slowly, painfully) that the person I was trying to reach wasn’t really available anymore. The addiction had taken over the part of him that could receive help. Every conversation eventually became about money. Every kindness became an opening to be used. I watched what it did to my parents. To my mother, who was already carrying so much. To my younger brother. To me.
So I did the thing I would tell any client they’re allowed to do. I stepped back. I told myself the door would be open the day he wanted to recover. Until then, I had to protect what was left of us.
The anger made that possible. Anger is clean. It has edges. It tells you where the boundary is and keeps you on the right side of it.
—————
There’s something that complicates all of this.
Steven wasn’t just my brother. Growing up, he was the person I spent much of my childhood bracing against. He bullied me. Some of what happened between us was traumatic, and I’ve spent real time in my own therapy working through it. I don’t have a store of good memories to return to. No golden childhood moment I can hold up against the end.
I loved him anyway. I showed up for him anyway, for as long as I could. Both of those things are true, and they have never sat comfortably together.
—————
And then he died, and the anger simply switched off.
I keep reaching for it, the way you reach for a light switch in a familiar room, and it isn’t there. What’s there instead is sadness. A heavy, quiet, bottomless kind of sadness. And something that feels a lot like regret.
I know, intellectually, that there was nothing more I could have done. I tried. Everyone tried. I know this the way you know something you’ve said to a hundred grieving clients. I don’t feel it yet. Feeling it is a different thing, and it’s slower.
What I’m beginning to understand is that the anger was never the whole story. It was protecting something. The grief was underneath it the entire time, and the anger stood in front of it like a guard, because I couldn’t afford to feel it while he was still out there, still alive, still capable of hurting us again. Now there’s nothing left to guard against. So the guard stepped aside.
—————
Somewhere during the process of grieving, I found myself asking: whose fault is this?
He made choices. I believe that. I won’t pretend he didn’t.
But I’m a psychodynamic therapist, and I can’t unknow what I know. Nobody arrives at a decade of addiction out of nowhere. There were things that shaped him long before the first drug: the way he was parented, the way he attached (or didn’t), the family he grew up inside, and yes, the dynamics between siblings...etc. I’m not blaming my parents. I’m not blaming myself. But I can’t say it was entirely his fault either.
And that thought devastates me. Because if it wasn’t entirely his fault, then he was also, in some way, a kid who got hurt and never found a way out. The boy who bullied me was probably carrying something too heavy for him. And no one, including him, was able to set it down.
I feel sorry for him. I feel devastated for him. I don’t know what to do with how much.
—————
I think “fault” might be the wrong shape for this question. Fault wants one answer and one person to hold it. Addiction doesn’t necessarily work that way. It’s choice and pain and biology and family and chance, tangled together so thoroughly that you can’t pull out a single thread and say, there, that one.
Maybe the question underneath “whose fault is this” is something closer to: am I allowed to grieve him?
Am I allowed to grieve a brother who hurt me? A brother I had to cut off? A brother I have very little good memories of?
I’m starting to think the answer is yes. Not because the hurt didn’t happen. Because the love did too, in its complicated, exhausted, imperfect way. And because underneath all of it, I’m not only grieving who he was. I’m grieving who he might have been. The brother I never got. The recovery that never came. The repair we didn’t have time for.
That kind of grief doesn’t have a tidy shape. I don’t think it’s supposed to.
—————
Rest, Steven. I hope wherever you are, it’s quieter than it was here.